If you have a lot of nice people on your holiday list—all of whom deserve unique, locally crafted, soulful gifts that no one else will think to give them—we’ve got you covered. From bitters that will spice up happy hour, to delicious and twee macaron snowmen, to botanical fragrances that deliver insta-Zen, there is something here for everyone on your list.
We selected tried-and-true favorites that offer a feast for the eyes and other senses. They are also made by independent, local producers who are as committed to sourcing locally and supporting the community as you are. Read on for fresh ideas that will make for a very merry holiday season.
Haikubox
Bird lovers will flock to Haikubox, a kind of Shazam for birds. The easy-to-install gadget uses sound to identify birds, records their songs, gathers data, and sends alerts so bird visitors are never missed.
From $199, haikubox.com
McMann & Tate Cocktail Co.
Moroccan Orange Bitters
Brighten your spirits, literally and metaphorically, with McMann & Tate’s Moroccan Orange Bitters! Zesty, spiced, and wildly aromatic, they are the perfect way to elevate holiday cocktails with citrus from around the world.
$14.99, mcmannandtatecocktailcompany.com
The Herbal Scoop
Herbal Tea Blends
Gift herbal tea that truly delivers. The Herbal Scoop’s farm-born-and-bred organic blends offer bold flavor, cozy comfort, and real wellness—perfect for gifting self-care and a more mindful sip.
From $12, theherbalscoop.com
The Callicoon Pantry
Holiday Snack Tins
These reusable, vibrant tins with sustainable, high-quality snacks are an easy gift or a nice treat. Bonus: Bring back the tins to refill at the Pantry for a discount when empty!
$28–$30, thecallicoonpantry.com
Seminary Hill
Orchard & Cidery
Small-Batch Cider from the Catskills
Make everyone on your list happy with still or sparkling cider from 60 apple and pear varieties grown on an organic hillside orchard at the world’s first Passive House–certified cidery.
From $24, seminaryhill.co
Main Course
Restaurant and Market
House-Made Holiday Treats
Main Course Restaurant and Market offers irresistible house-made holiday treats—from charming macaron snowmen and decadent truffles to classic peppermint bark and outrageously good butter toffee with almonds and pecans—perfect for everyone on your list.
From $14, maincoursecatering.com
Fortuna’s Sausage
Around the Italian Dinner Table
Celebrate food, family, and togetherness with this curated gift box—everything you need to enjoy meaningful meals and continue the “family dinner” tradition, delivered with care to loved ones nationwide.
From $79.95, fortunasausage.com
Brooklyn Cider House
Club Membership
Give the gift that keeps on giving with a membership offering three- or six-bottle quarterly releases, discount on all other bottles, free tasting flights, a free cidery tour, exclusive club events, and notes from the cidermakers.
From $76.50, brooklynciderhouse.com
Wndrmade
Pure Botanical Fragrances
Wndrmade crafts pure botanical fragrances for mindful living, ideal for gifting during the busy season. Each candle and perfume blends nature’s finest ingredients to elevate everyday rituals with calm, beauty, and intention.
From $10, wndrmade.com
Settepani
Rainbow Panettone
Brooklyn’s Settepani Bakery blends Italian tradition with American creativity, reimagining panettone with fun, Instagram-ready flavors and designs like the Rainbow Panettone—Bilena Settepani’s tribute to the classic tri-color cookie.
$74.95, settepani.com
Tenmile Distillery
Revolutionary Whisky: The Battle of Stoney Point Gift Box
Tenmile Distillery is celebrating America’s 250th with a set of whiskies commemorating the Revolutionary War! Get your favorite history buff this gift box with one (1) bottle of single malt, two tumblers, and a jigger.
$135, newyorkcraftspirits.com
Buck Brook Alpacas
Alpaca Arte Socks (Our Herd)
Buck Brook Alpacas offers an array of stylish handmade alpaca products, crafted from the fleece of a herd raised in the highest peaks of the Catskill Mountains. Gift the gift of unmatched comfort with Our Herd socks.
$28, buckbrookalpacas.com
